Welcome to the Catholic Hangout
Church Music-The Good, The Bad, and The Ugly
#1
Earlier today, I posted a music track on Your Favorite Music Tracks, which was an example of the use of Gregorian chant in popular music in the late 1960s, which was when the Church was throwing it out. The virtual elimination of Gregorian chant was in direct contradiction to the Vatican II document on the liturgy. Apparently, the world saw the value of chant even at a time when many in the Church saw it as outdated. Then I went to mass at a parish that is not my regular parish. The mass started out with a song (I am hesitant to call it a hymn), which is an obvious rip off of Dave Brubeck's "Take Five." The song borders on plagiarism, except that you cannot plagiarize a 5/4 time signature. I found the use of drums in the song not to be conducive to creating a proper environment for prayer. Fortunately, when the mass began, the priest used Gregorian chant for the Gloria and many of the responses. This was certainly a positive. However, it was too soon back to the mediocre music and the irritating drums. The use of the drums in the Communion hymn was especially irritating, since it made it hard to focus on prayer. Ironically, the best contemporary music in the mass today was a hymn written and originally sung by a Protestant, "He Is Exalted" by Twila Paris. There are parishes that do the mass reverently and maybe the solution is just to avoid this mass at this particular parish in the future. Do any of you struggle with mediocre music and inappropriate instrumentation at mass and, if so, what is your solution?
Reply


Messages In This Thread
Church Music-The Good, The Bad, and The Ugly - by enchantmentadm - 10-27-2024, 10:10 PM

Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)

About Catholic Hangout

To post or comment on any threads on this Catholic Hangout, you must be a registered member. Registration is quick and free, so if you'd like to participate, please sign up!

Catholic Hangout is a sanctuary for those who are part of the Catholic community to unite in fellowship. Whether you are a practicing Catholic, in the process of joining the Catholic faith, or perhaps have strayed from the church and are seeking a path back, you are warmly welcomed here. This is a place of acceptance and understanding, where everyone, regardless of their journey in faith, can find a sense of belonging. We are here to support and uplift each other in our shared Catholic faith. Welcome to our community!

              Quick Links

              User Links